Chapter 9: The Trinity, Human Nature, and the Evidence from Near Death Experiences

Understanding How the Triune God Created Humans as Body-Soul Unities and What NDEs Reveal About Our Nature

Opening: When the Veil Grows Thin

Dr. Pim van Lommel, a Dutch cardiologist, was reviewing patient charts when he noticed something remarkable. A patient who had been clinically dead for several minutes during cardiac arrest later described in vivid detail what had happened in the operating room while he had no measurable brain activity. The patient accurately reported conversations, described medical procedures, and even correctly identified where his dentures had been placed – all while his brain showed no signs of functioning. This wasn’t an isolated case. Van Lommel went on to conduct one of the most rigorous studies of Near Death Experiences ever undertaken, published in The Lancet medical journal in 2001, documenting similar experiences in numerous patients.

Stories like these raise profound questions about human nature. If consciousness can exist when the brain isn’t functioning, what does this tell us about who we are as human beings? Are we purely physical beings whose consciousness emerges from brain chemistry? Or are we, as Christians have traditionally believed, both body and soul – created in the image of a God who is Himself spirit? And most importantly for our study, how does the doctrine of the Trinity help us understand these questions?

The debate over human nature isn’t just academic. It touches the very core of Christian faith. If humans are purely physical beings, as physicalists argue, then what happens to consciousness at death? Some Christians who embrace physicalism have adopted “conditional immortality” – the view that the soul doesn’t naturally survive death but must be recreated by God at the resurrection. Others hold to “soul sleep” – the idea that consciousness ceases between death and resurrection. But if humans have an immaterial soul that can exist apart from the body, as dualists maintain, then consciousness continues after death, just as Christians have traditionally believed.

Near Death Experiences have emerged as one of the most intriguing phenomena in this debate. Millions of people worldwide have reported experiences of consciousness during clinical death – times when their brains showed no activity. They describe leaving their bodies, encountering deceased relatives, experiencing supernatural peace, seeing beings of light, and undergoing life reviews. While skeptics offer naturalistic explanations, the veridical (verifiable) elements of many NDEs – where patients accurately report events they couldn’t have physically observed – challenge purely physicalist explanations of consciousness.

But what does any of this have to do with the Trinity? Everything, as we’ll see. The triune nature of God provides the theological framework for understanding human nature. We are created in the image of a God who is three persons in one essence – a God who is both unity and distinction, both one and many. This Trinitarian understanding helps us navigate between the extremes of reductive physicalism (we’re just bodies) and gnostic dualism (the body is evil or unimportant). Just as the Trinity teaches us that God is neither a simple monad nor three separate beings, so the Trinity helps us understand that humans are neither purely physical machines nor ghosts trapped in biological prisons.

Section 1: The Trinity and the Image of God

Genesis 1:26-27 records one of the most profound statements in all of Scripture: “Then God said, ‘Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness’… So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them” (NKJV). Notice the plural language – “Let Us make man in Our image.” As we’ve seen throughout this book, this plurality in unity points to the Trinity. But what does it mean to be made in the image of the triune God?

Throughout church history, theologians have understood the image of God to include our immaterial aspect – what Scripture calls the soul or spirit. Irenaeus of Lyons (130-202 AD) wrote: “For that flesh which has been moulded is not a perfect man in itself, but the body of a man, and part of a man. Neither is the soul itself, considered apart by itself, the man; but it is the soul of a man, and part of a man… But when the spirit here blended with the soul is united to God’s creation, the spiritual and perfect man is formed, and this is he who was made in the image and likeness of God” (Against Heresies, V.6.1).

Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD) saw the Trinity reflected in human consciousness itself. He identified triadic structures in the human mind – memory, understanding, and will – that mirror the three persons of the Godhead. In his work “On the Trinity,” Augustine argued that these mental faculties are distinct yet inseparable, just as the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are distinct persons yet one God. This isn’t to say humans are three persons, but rather that the complexity and unity of human consciousness reflects something of the triune God who created us.

Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) developed this further, arguing that the human soul, being created in God’s image, must be immaterial and subsistent – capable of existing apart from the body, though naturally united to it. He wrote: “The human soul is in the image of God in such a way that it can know God, love God, and be happy in God. But this would not be possible unless the soul had an immaterial and subsistent nature” (Summa Theologiae I.93.2).

This traditional understanding sees humans as psychosomatic unities – integrated beings of body and soul. We’re not souls imprisoned in bodies (as Plato taught) nor are we purely physical beings (as materialists claim). Rather, like the Trinity itself, we are both unified and complex, both one and distinguishable into aspects. The body without the soul is dead (James 2:26), but the soul without the body is incomplete, which is why Scripture promises not just spiritual salvation but bodily resurrection.

Section 2: The Biblical Case for Dualism

When we turn to Scripture with the Trinity in mind, we find abundant evidence that humans are more than purely physical beings. The Bible consistently presents humans as having both material and immaterial aspects, often using the terms “soul” (Hebrew: nephesh; Greek: psychē) and “spirit” (Hebrew: ruach; Greek: pneuma) to describe our immaterial nature.

Old Testament Foundations

The very creation account suggests human complexity. Genesis 2:7 states: “And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul” (NKJV). Notice the pattern: God forms the physical body from dust, then breathes into it the breath of life (the Hebrew neshamah often refers to the spiritual aspect), and only then does man become a “living soul” (nephesh chayah). This suggests humans are more than just animated matter – we have a God-breathed spiritual dimension.

Ecclesiastes 12:7 explicitly describes what happens at death: “Then the dust will return to the earth as it was, and the spirit will return to God who gave it” (NKJV). This clearly distinguishes between the physical body that returns to dust and the spirit that returns to God. If humans were purely physical, this statement would make no sense.

The Old Testament also records several instances suggesting consciousness after death. When Saul consulted the medium at Endor (1 Samuel 28), the prophet Samuel appeared and spoke, though he had died. While some argue this was demonic deception, the text presents it as actually being Samuel, who accurately prophesied Saul’s impending death. This implies Samuel’s consciousness continued after physical death.

New Testament Evidence

Jesus Himself taught the distinction between body and soul. In Matthew 10:28, He warned: “And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. But rather fear Him who is able to destroy both soul and body in hell” (NKJV). This statement makes no sense if the soul is merely a function of the body. If physicalism were true, killing the body would automatically “kill” the soul.

Christ’s parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) depicts conscious existence immediately after death. Both men experience awareness, memory, and communication in the afterlife, before any resurrection. While some argue this is “just a parable,” Jesus never based His parables on falsehoods. If conscious existence after death were impossible, this parable would be fundamentally misleading.

Perhaps most significantly, Jesus promised the thief on the cross: “Assuredly, I say to you, today you will be with Me in Paradise” (Luke 23:43, NKJV). Not “today your soul will sleep until the resurrection” or “today you will cease to exist until I recreate you.” The thief would be consciously with Christ that very day, even though his body would be dead.

The apostle Paul explicitly taught that believers could exist apart from their bodies. In 2 Corinthians 5:6-8, he wrote: “So we are always confident, knowing that while we are at home in the body we are absent from the Lord… We are confident, yes, well pleased rather to be absent from the body and to be present with the Lord” (NKJV). Paul envisions a state of being “absent from the body” yet “present with the Lord” – conscious existence without physical embodiment.

Even more explicitly, in Philippians 1:21-23, Paul states: “For to me, to live is Christ, and to die is gain… For I am hard-pressed between the two, having a desire to depart and be with Christ, which is far better” (NKJV). If death meant unconsciousness or non-existence until the resurrection, how could it be “gain” or “far better”? Paul clearly expected conscious fellowship with Christ immediately upon death.

The book of Revelation depicts the souls of martyrs consciously existing in heaven before the resurrection: “When He opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of those who had been slain for the word of God… And they cried with a loud voice, saying, ‘How long, O Lord, holy and true, until You judge and avenge our blood on those who dwell on the earth?'” (Revelation 6:9-10, NKJV). These souls are conscious, communicating, and aware of earthly events even though their bodies remain unresurrected.

Section 3: Near Death Experiences – Evidence for the Soul?

In recent decades, medical technology has created an unprecedented situation: people can be brought back from clinical death. During these episodes, millions have reported extraordinary experiences that suggest consciousness continues when the brain ceases functioning. These Near Death Experiences (NDEs) have become one of the most studied phenomena in modern medicine, with profound implications for understanding human nature.

The Phenomenon of NDEs

Near Death Experiences typically occur during cardiac arrest, severe trauma, or other life-threatening situations where brain function is severely compromised or absent. Common elements include:

What makes NDEs particularly significant for the dualism debate is that they often occur when the brain shows no measurable activity. During cardiac arrest, the brain typically ceases functioning within 20 seconds due to lack of oxygen. EEG readings go flat, indicating no electrical activity. Yet patients later report vivid, coherent experiences during these periods of brain inactivity.

Veridical NDEs – The Evidential Gold Standard

While skeptics argue that NDEs might be hallucinations caused by dying brain chemistry, veridical (verified) NDEs present a serious challenge to physicalist explanations. These are cases where patients report information they couldn’t have known through normal sensory means, later confirmed as accurate.

The Pam Reynolds Case: One of the most documented cases involved Pam Reynolds, who underwent surgery for a brain aneurysm in 1991. Her body temperature was lowered to 60 degrees, her heart stopped, and blood was drained from her brain – a state called “standstill.” With no blood in her brain and no measurable brain activity, she should have been completely unconscious. Yet Reynolds later described in detail:

• The unusual saw used to open her skull (she correctly described it as looking like an electric toothbrush)
• Conversations between medical staff about her arteries being too small
• The specific music playing at different points during surgery
• Which staff members were present and where they stood

Dr. Robert Spetzler, the neurosurgeon who performed the operation, confirmed her observations were accurate, stating: “I don’t think the observations she made were based on what she experienced as she went into the operating theater. They were just not available to her. For instance, the drill was not unpacked until after she was under anesthesia.”

The AWARE Study: In 2014, Dr. Sam Parnia published results from the AWARE (AWAreness during REsuscitation) study, the largest scientific study of NDEs to date. The study placed images on shelves that could only be seen from above, testing whether patients reporting out-of-body experiences could identify them. While most cardiac arrests occurred in areas without the shelves, one patient accurately described events during a three-minute period when his brain showed no activity, including specific sounds and activities later verified by medical staff.

Kenneth Ring’s Research: Psychologist Kenneth Ring documented numerous cases of blind people, including those blind from birth, who reported visual experiences during NDEs. Vicki Umipeg, blind from birth due to premature birth complications, reported during her NDE that she could see for the first time – she saw her body, the hospital room, and even her wedding rings. She had never seen anything before and had no concept of sight, yet accurately described visual details later confirmed by others.

The Dutch Prospective Study: Cardiologist Pim van Lommel conducted a prospective study of 344 cardiac arrest patients in the Netherlands. Published in The Lancet, the study found that 18% reported NDEs, with 8% reporting “core” experiences. Significantly, these experiences occurred during periods when the brain was clinically non-functional. Van Lommel concluded: “How could a clear consciousness outside one’s body be experienced at the moment that the brain no longer functions during a period of clinical death with flat EEG?… The thus far assumed, but never proven, concept that consciousness and memories are localized in the brain should be questioned.”

NDEs and the Biblical Worldview

How should Christians evaluate NDEs? While we must be cautious about building doctrine on experiences, NDEs align remarkably well with biblical teaching about human nature and the afterlife. Consider these parallels:

1. Consciousness After Death: NDEs confirm what Scripture teaches – that consciousness continues after physical death. This matches Paul’s expectation of being “absent from the body and present with the Lord.”

2. The Spiritual Realm: NDErs consistently report encountering a spiritual dimension more real than physical reality. This aligns with the biblical teaching that “the things which are seen are temporary, but the things which are not seen are eternal” (2 Corinthians 4:18).

3. Judgment and Life Review: Many NDErs experience a life review where they see their actions from others’ perspectives, feeling the pain or joy they caused. This resonates with biblical teaching about judgment and the principle that “whatever a man sows, that he will also reap” (Galatians 6:7).

4. Divine Love and Light: The “being of light” frequently reported in NDEs, characterized by unconditional love, matches the biblical description of God as light (1 John 1:5) and love (1 John 4:8).

5. Transformation: NDErs typically return with decreased fear of death, increased spirituality, and greater love for others – fruits consistent with genuine spiritual experience.

However, Christians must also exercise discernment. Not all NDE accounts align with biblical truth. Some report universalist messages (“everyone goes to heaven”), reincarnation beliefs, or New Age concepts. This reminds us that spiritual experiences must be tested against Scripture (1 John 4:1). The fact that NDEs occur doesn’t mean every interpretation or message within them is accurate.

Section 4: The Physicalist Challenge and Conditional Immortality

Not all Christians accept the traditional dualist understanding of human nature. In recent decades, some theologians and philosophers have embraced physicalism – the view that humans are purely physical beings without immaterial souls. This has led to alternative views about death and resurrection, particularly the doctrine of “conditional immortality.”

The Rise of Christian Physicalism

Christian physicalists argue that advances in neuroscience show consciousness depends entirely on brain function. They point to how brain injuries can alter personality, how drugs affect consciousness, and how specific brain regions correlate with particular mental functions. Theologians like Nancey Murphy, Joel Green, and others argue that the Bible’s language about “soul” doesn’t refer to an immaterial substance but to the whole person or life itself.

These scholars often claim that dualism is a Greek philosophical import, foreign to Hebrew thought. They argue that the Hebrew Bible presents humans holistically, not as divided beings. When Genesis says humans “became living souls,” they interpret this as meaning humans became living beings, not that they received immaterial souls.

The physicalist view has significant implications. If humans are purely physical, then when the body dies, the person ceases to exist entirely. This leads to two main options:

Problems with Christian Physicalism

While physicalists claim scientific support, their position faces serious philosophical and theological problems:

1. The Hard Problem of Consciousness: Physicalism cannot explain how subjective conscious experience arises from objective physical processes. How does the firing of neurons produce the qualitative experience of seeing red, feeling pain, or experiencing love? This “explanatory gap” remains unbridged despite decades of neuroscience research. As philosopher David Chalmers notes, we can imagine philosophical zombies – beings physically identical to humans but lacking conscious experience – which suggests consciousness is more than physical processes.

2. Personal Identity Through Time: If we are purely physical, what maintains personal identity? Our bodies completely replace their atoms every seven years. If you are just your body, you’re literally not the same person you were seven years ago. The soul provides continuity of identity that purely physical accounts cannot.

3. The Resurrection Problem: If humans cease to exist at death, then resurrection isn’t bringing the same person back to life – it’s creating a copy. Imagine God creating an exact duplicate of you right now. That duplicate would have your memories and personality, but would it be you? Most would say no – it would be a copy. But that’s exactly what physicalist resurrection entails. The traditional view that the soul survives death solves this problem – the same soul that left the body is reunited with a glorified body.

4. Biblical Interpretation Issues: Physicalists must radically reinterpret numerous biblical passages. When Jesus tells the thief “today you will be with me in Paradise,” physicalists must argue Jesus meant “today I’m telling you that eventually you’ll be with me” or find other creative interpretations. When Paul speaks of being “absent from the body, present with the Lord,” physicalists must claim Paul was confused or speaking hypothetically. This requires overturning two thousand years of Christian interpretation.

5. The Intermediate State: Scripture clearly teaches conscious existence between death and resurrection. Moses and Elijah appear at the Transfiguration, though they had died centuries earlier. The souls under the altar in Revelation cry out for justice. Paul desires to “depart and be with Christ.” Physicalism cannot account for this intermediate state without massive reinterpretation.

6. Free Will and Moral Responsibility: If humans are purely physical, then our thoughts and choices are simply the result of prior physical causes – atoms bumping into atoms according to the laws of physics. This makes free will an illusion and moral responsibility meaningless. But Scripture holds humans genuinely responsible for their choices, which requires something more than physical determinism.

Conditional Immortality’s Theological Problems

Conditional immortality – the view that souls don’t naturally survive death – creates additional theological difficulties:

The Trinity itself argues against physicalism. God is three persons without physical bodies (the Father and Spirit were never incarnate, and the Son existed before incarnation). If personhood requires a physical body, as physicalists claim, then God couldn’t be personal. But Scripture reveals a personal, relational God who created us in His image. Just as God is spirit, we have a spiritual dimension that transcends the physical.

Section 5: NDEs and the Trinitarian Framework

When we examine NDEs through a Trinitarian lens, remarkable patterns emerge that physicalism cannot explain but which align beautifully with orthodox Christian theology.

Relational Consciousness

The Trinity reveals that ultimate reality is inherently relational – three persons in eternal communion. NDEs consistently emphasize relational aspects of consciousness:

Meeting Deceased Loved Ones: One of the most common NDE elements is encountering deceased relatives or friends. These aren’t vague presences but specific individuals with whom the experiencer interacts. This suggests consciousness after death retains personal identity and relational capacity – exactly what we’d expect if humans image the relational Trinity.

Dr. Jeffrey Long’s Near Death Experience Research Foundation has documented over 5,000 NDEs. In his analysis, 57% reported meeting deceased relatives or friends. Remarkably, young children sometimes report meeting relatives they didn’t know had died, or even relatives they’d never heard of, later verified by family members. This suggests genuine contact, not wishful thinking.

The Being of Light: Most NDErs who encounter a divine presence describe it in deeply personal, relational terms. The being knows them completely, loves them unconditionally, and communicates through direct thought transfer. This matches the biblical revelation of a personal God who “knows the thoughts and intents of the heart” (Hebrews 4:12). The trinitarian God is not an impersonal force but three persons in relationship, and NDEs reflect this personal divine reality.

Life Review as Relational Assessment: During life reviews, experiencers don’t just see their actions – they experience them from others’ perspectives, feeling the impact of their choices on other people. This profound emphasis on how we’ve affected others reflects the relational nature of morality rooted in the Trinity. Sin isn’t just breaking rules but damaging relationships – with God and others.

Unity and Distinction

Just as the Trinity maintains both unity (one God) and distinction (three persons), NDEs reveal human consciousness maintaining both connection and individuality after death:

Expanded Yet Individual Consciousness: NDErs often report a paradoxical expansion of awareness while maintaining individual identity. They may experience cosmic consciousness or unity with all things, yet remain distinctly themselves. Howard Storm, an atheist art professor who had an NDE, described it: “I knew everything and was everything, yet I was still me.” This mirrors the perichoresis of the Trinity – complete interpenetration while maintaining distinct personhood.

Telepathic Yet Personal Communication: Communication in NDEs typically occurs through direct thought transfer, yet maintains the distinction between persons. Experiencers know others’ thoughts but remain separate individuals. This reflects the Trinity’s perfect communication and knowledge while maintaining personal distinctions.

The Spiritual Nature of Ultimate Reality

The Trinity reveals God as Spirit (John 4:24), and NDEs consistently point to consciousness/spirit as more fundamental than matter:

Enhanced Consciousness Without Brain Function: Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of NDEs is that consciousness often seems enhanced when the brain is most compromised. Experiencers report 360-degree vision, ability to see through walls, instant access to knowledge, and clarity of thought exceeding normal waking consciousness. Dr. Eben Alexander, a neurosurgeon who had an NDE during a coma caused by bacterial meningitis that destroyed his neocortex, wrote: “My experience showed me that the brain does not produce consciousness… consciousness exists independently of the brain.”

The “Realer Than Real” Quality: NDErs consistently describe their experience as “more real than ordinary reality.” They don’t say it seemed like a dream or hallucination – quite the opposite. Years later, the NDE remains vivid while ordinary memories fade. This suggests they’ve encountered a higher reality – the spiritual realm that underlies physical existence, just as the Trinity underlies creation.

Information Beyond Brain Access: Veridical NDEs involve acquiring information the brain couldn’t access. Pam Reynolds’ brain had no blood flow. Vicki Umipeg’s brain had never processed visual information. Yet both reported accurate observations. This points to consciousness operating independently of the brain, just as the triune God exists independently of creation.

Love as Ultimate Reality

The Trinity reveals that God is love (1 John 4:8) – not just that God has love, but that His very being is love expressed eternally between Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. NDEs overwhelmingly emphasize love as the fundamental reality:

Unconditional Divine Love: The most transformative aspect of NDEs is experiencing unconditional love from the being of light. Experiencers struggle to describe it, often saying earthly love pales in comparison. This love knows everything about them yet accepts them completely. This matches the trinitarian understanding – we’re loved by a God whose very nature is love.

Love as the Life Review’s Focus: During life reviews, the central question isn’t about religious observance or doctrinal correctness but about love. “How well did you love?” becomes the crucial assessment. This aligns with Jesus’s teaching that the greatest commandments involve love of God and neighbor (Matthew 22:36-40).

Transformed Capacity for Love: NDErs typically return with dramatically increased capacity for love and compassion. They become less judgmental, more forgiving, more concerned for others’ wellbeing. This transformation reflects exposure to the source of love – the triune God who is love itself.

Section 6: Theological Implications for Human Nature

The convergence of trinitarian theology, biblical anthropology, and NDE research points toward profound truths about human nature that impact every aspect of Christian life and doctrine.

We Are More Than Matter

The evidence from NDEs, combined with biblical teaching and trinitarian theology, strongly supports substance dualism – humans possess both physical bodies and immaterial souls. This isn’t the Platonic dualism that denigrates the body, but biblical holistic dualism that values both aspects of human nature.

We are embodied souls and ensouled bodies. The body isn’t a prison for the soul (as Gnostics taught) nor is the soul merely an emergent property of the body (as physicalists claim). Both are good, both are created by God, and both are essential to complete human nature. This is why Scripture promises not just spiritual salvation but bodily resurrection.

The Trinity provides the model – distinction without separation, unity without confusion. Father, Son, and Spirit are distinct yet inseparable; similarly, body and soul are distinguishable yet naturally united. Just as the Trinity isn’t three gods (tritheism) or one person appearing in three modes (modalism), humans aren’t two separate beings (Cartesian dualism) or purely physical entities (physicalism).

Death is Separation, Not Cessation

If NDEs provide genuine glimpses of consciousness after clinical death, they confirm the biblical teaching that death is separation, not cessation. Physical death separates soul from body, but the soul continues to exist consciously. This makes sense of numerous biblical passages:

• Why Paul could say “to die is gain” (Philippians 1:21)
• How Moses and Elijah could appear at the Transfiguration
• Why Jesus promised immediate Paradise to the thief
• How martyrs’ souls can cry out from under the altar
• Why believers are called “asleep” rather than “ceased to exist”

This understanding profoundly impacts how we view death. For believers, death isn’t the end but a transition – tragic in its separation but temporary in duration. The soul goes to be with Christ awaiting resurrection when soul and body reunite in glorified form. NDEs, with their consistent reports of consciousness beyond clinical death, provide experiential confirmation of this biblical hope.

The Image of God Includes Immortality

If humans are created in the image of the eternal, triune God, then we must possess an eternal aspect. God doesn’t create and destroy His image bearers like disposable products. The immortality of the soul reflects the eternity of God. Just as the three persons of the Trinity exist eternally, the human soul, created in that image, exists eternally.

This doesn’t mean humans are inherently immortal apart from God – our immortality is derived and dependent. But once God creates a human soul in His image, that soul continues to exist. This is why hell is eternal conscious punishment rather than annihilation – even in rebellion, humans remain image bearers whose existence God sustains.

Conditional immortality’s claim that souls naturally perish contradicts the imago Dei. If bearing God’s image doesn’t include a naturally surviving soul, then we don’t truly image the eternal God. NDEs, showing consciousness continuing when the brain stops, suggest the soul does indeed naturally survive bodily death, just as Christian theology has always taught.

Consciousness is Fundamental, Not Emergent

The Trinity reveals that consciousness – personal awareness and relationship – is fundamental to reality, not an emergent property of matter. The Father, Son, and Spirit existed in conscious relationship before any physical creation. Consciousness, therefore, is prior to and more fundamental than matter.

This reverses the physicalist assumption. Physicalists argue consciousness emerges from sufficiently complex physical processes. But if the triune God is the source of reality, then consciousness is primary and matter derivative. Matter exists because conscious divine persons chose to create it. NDEs support this priority – consciousness appears more fundamental than physical processes, continuing and even expanding when the brain shuts down.

This has profound implications for understanding human nature. We’re not biological machines that developed consciousness as a survival tool. We’re conscious beings created by conscious divine persons for conscious relationship with them. Our consciousness reflects and participates in divine consciousness, which explains why consciousness seems irreducible to physical processes – it’s not meant to be reduced because it’s more fundamental than the physical.

Relational Purpose Defines Human Existence

The Trinity shows that relationship, not isolation, is ultimate reality. The Father, Son, and Spirit exist in eternal communion. Humans, created in this image, are fundamentally relational beings designed for relationship with God and others.

NDEs consistently emphasize this relational purpose. Life reviews focus on relationships – how we’ve loved or failed to love others. The most profound aspects involve encountering divine love and reuniting with loved ones. Experiencers return understanding that relationships, not achievements or possessions, matter most.

This confirms the biblical priority of love. When asked about the greatest commandment, Jesus didn’t mention ritual observance or doctrinal precision but love – love for God and neighbor (Matthew 22:36-40). Paul writes that without love, all spiritual gifts and sacrifices amount to nothing (1 Corinthians 13:1-3). John declares that whoever doesn’t love doesn’t know God, because God is love (1 John 4:8).

The relational emphasis in NDEs isn’t New Age sentimentalism but reflects the trinitarian structure of reality. We exist for relationship because we’re created by a relational God. The soul’s survival after death ensures these relationships can continue and ultimately be perfected in the resurrection.

Section 7: Answering Objections

Critics of using NDEs as evidence for dualism raise several objections that deserve careful responses.

Objection 1: “NDEs Are Just Hallucinations”

The Objection: Skeptics argue NDEs result from oxygen deprivation, endorphin release, or dying brain chemistry producing hallucinations. The experiences aren’t real but biochemical illusions.

Response: This explanation fails on multiple levels:

First, veridical NDEs involve accurate observation of events the person couldn’t have seen. Hallucinations don’t provide accurate information about external reality. When Pam Reynolds correctly described surgical instruments she’d never seen while her brain had no blood flow, this wasn’t hallucination but observation.

Second, NDEs often occur when the brain shows no activity. During cardiac arrest, the brain typically flatlines within 20 seconds. Complex, coherent experiences during this time contradict the hallucination hypothesis, which requires brain activity.

Third, NDEs have consistent structure across cultures, ages, and backgrounds. Hallucinations are typically random and culturally conditioned. The consistent elements of NDEs suggest encounter with objective reality, not subjective hallucination.

Fourth, NDEs produce lasting life transformation. People don’t restructure their entire lives based on hallucinations. The profound and permanent changes following NDEs – decreased death anxiety, increased spirituality, greater compassion – suggest genuine spiritual encounter.

Fifth, some NDEs occur without any physiological crisis. People have reported them during meditation, childbirth, or even spontaneously. This eliminates dying brain chemistry as the sole cause.

Objection 2: “Brain Activity Explains Everything”

The Objection: Physicalists argue that correlation between brain states and mental states proves the brain produces consciousness. Damage specific brain regions, lose specific functions. Alter brain chemistry, alter consciousness. Therefore, no brain equals no consciousness.

Response: Correlation doesn’t prove causation. Consider a TV analogy: damage the TV, and the picture distorts. Destroy the TV, and the picture disappears. But this doesn’t mean the TV creates the signal – it receives and displays it. Similarly, the brain may receive and express consciousness without producing it.

The evidence from NDEs suggests exactly this. When the brain “TV” shuts down, consciousness doesn’t cease but continues, sometimes with greater clarity. This suggests the brain constrains and channels consciousness rather than creating it.

Furthermore, the hard problem of consciousness remains unsolved. No one has explained how objective brain processes produce subjective conscious experience. The explanatory gap between neurons firing and the experience of seeing red or feeling love remains unbridged. NDEs suggest why – consciousness isn’t reducible to brain processes because it’s not produced by them.

Additionally, some phenomena suggest consciousness affecting the brain rather than just being affected by it. Neuroplasticity research shows that conscious practices like meditation physically alter brain structure. Placebo effects demonstrate consciousness influencing physical healing. The relationship between brain and consciousness appears bidirectional, not unidirectional as physicalism requires.

Objection 3: “NDEs Contradict Each Other”

The Objection: NDEs sometimes contain conflicting elements. Some see Jesus, others Buddha. Some report judgment, others universal acceptance. These contradictions show NDEs are culturally conditioned projections, not glimpses of objective reality.

Response: While NDEs show cultural variation in interpretation and specific imagery, core elements remain remarkably consistent: leaving the body, encountering deceased persons, experiencing a loving presence, undergoing life review, and returning transformed.

The variations often reflect interpretive frameworks rather than contradictory experiences. A Christian may interpret the being of light as Jesus, a Hindu as Krishna, but both encounter a loving divine presence. This is what we’d expect – humans interpreting transcendent experience through their conceptual frameworks.

Moreover, not all spiritual experiences are equally valid or complete. The Bible warns about deceptive spirits (1 John 4:1) and Satan appearing as an angel of light (2 Corinthians 11:14). Some NDE content may be deceptive or misinterpreted. Christians must test experiences against Scripture, accepting what aligns with biblical truth while rejecting what contradicts it.

The core elements of NDEs that consistently appear – consciousness surviving bodily death, encountering divine love, life assessment based on love, transformation toward compassion – align remarkably well with biblical teaching. The variations often concern secondary details or interpretations rather than these fundamental aspects.

Objection 4: “This Promotes Experience Over Scripture”

The Objection: Some Christians worry that appealing to NDEs elevates experience over biblical authority. Shouldn’t Scripture alone determine our theology?

Response: Scripture remains the ultimate authority, but God also reveals truth through creation (Romans 1:20) and experience. NDEs don’t determine doctrine but can illustrate and confirm biblical teaching, much like archaeology confirms biblical history without replacing Scripture’s authority.

The Bible itself records numerous visionary experiences – Isaiah’s throne room vision, Ezekiel’s wheels, Paul’s third heaven journey, John’s Revelation. These experiences didn’t create doctrine but conveyed truth consistent with God’s broader revelation. Similarly, modern NDEs can illustrate biblical truths about consciousness, death, and the afterlife without replacing Scripture.

Furthermore, the physicalist position also relies on experience – specifically, neuroscience research. If Christians can’t cite NDEs because they’re experiential, then physicalists can’t cite brain studies either. Both sides interpret experience through theological frameworks. The question isn’t whether to consider experience but how to properly interpret it through biblical lenses.

We’re not building doctrine on NDEs but recognizing how they confirm what Scripture already teaches – that humans have souls that survive death, that consciousness continues after physical death, that God is love, and that how we love matters eternally. NDEs illustrate these truths in powerful contemporary ways without replacing biblical authority.

Section 8: Practical Applications for Christian Life

Understanding human nature through the lens of Trinity and the evidence from NDEs isn’t merely academic – it profoundly impacts how we live as Christians.

Confidence in the Face of Death

If consciousness survives bodily death, as NDEs suggest and Scripture teaches, death loses its ultimate sting. Paul’s triumphant declaration makes perfect sense: “O Death, where is your sting? O Hades, where is your victory?” (1 Corinthians 15:55, NKJV).

This doesn’t minimize death’s tragedy – it still separates us from loved ones and disrupts God’s created order. But death becomes a defeated enemy, a temporary separation rather than final termination. Believers can face death knowing it’s a transition to Christ’s presence, not cessation of existence.

NDEs consistently report that death itself is peaceful, even blissful. The fear and pain occur before death, but the transition brings peace and often joy. While we shouldn’t seek death, we need not fear it. As one experiencer said, “Death is safe. It’s like walking from one room into another, except the second room is incomparably more beautiful.”

For those grieving lost loved ones, understanding consciousness survives brings comfort. Our deceased Christian loved ones aren’t unconscious or non-existent but alive with Christ, awaiting resurrection. The separation is real and painful, but temporary. NDEs suggesting continued awareness and identity after death confirm this biblical hope.

Eternal Perspective on Daily Life

If NDEs accurately reflect that our lives are reviewed with emphasis on love and relationships, this should radically reorient our priorities. Career success, wealth accumulation, and social status – while not inherently evil – pale compared to eternal relational realities.

Jesus’s teaching takes on renewed urgency: “Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal; but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven” (Matthew 6:19-20, NKJV). The treasures in heaven aren’t abstract rewards but the relationships we’ve built, the love we’ve shared, the people we’ve influenced for God’s kingdom.

Every interaction becomes spiritually significant. The harsh word to a spouse, the kindness to a stranger, the patience with a difficult child – these aren’t just momentary events but eternal investments. NDErs consistently report that seemingly small acts of love had profound significance in their life reviews. As one said, “I saw that every act of love, no matter how small, rippled out affecting countless people in ways I never imagined.”

Understanding Our True Identity

Recognizing we’re embodied souls created in God’s triune image transforms self-understanding. We’re not advanced animals driven by survival instincts, nor are we purely spiritual beings trapped in flesh. We’re image bearers of the Trinity – complex unities of body and soul designed for eternal relationship with God.

This impacts how we treat our bodies. They’re not prisons to escape (Gnosticism) or gods to worship (materialism) but temples of the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 6:19). We care for our bodies as good gifts from God while recognizing they’re not our ultimate identity.

It also impacts how we view consciousness and spirituality. Our thoughts, emotions, and spiritual experiences aren’t just brain chemistry but aspects of our souls that will survive death. This makes spiritual disciplines like prayer, meditation, and worship investments in eternal reality, not just psychological exercises.

Ministry to the Dying

Understanding consciousness continues through death changes how we minister to dying people. Even when someone appears unconscious, their soul may be aware. Many NDErs report hearing conversations while clinically dead. This means we should:

• Continue speaking to unconscious dying people
• Pray audibly in their presence
• Share Scripture and hymns they loved
• Express love and grant forgiveness
• Avoid discussing them as if they’re not present

Healthcare workers report that hearing is often the last sense to fade. Combined with NDE accounts of awareness during clinical death, this suggests ministry to the dying continues even when they can’t respond. A woman whose mother died while she was reading Psalm 23 later met an NDEr who reported, “I heard my daughter reading Scripture as I left my body, and it guided me toward the light.”

Evangelistic Opportunities

NDEs provide powerful evangelistic bridges in our secular culture. Many people who reject traditional religious claims remain open to NDE accounts. These experiences open conversations about spiritual reality, life after death, and ultimate meaning.

When sharing faith with skeptics, NDEs offer evidence that:

• Consciousness isn’t merely material
• Death isn’t the end
• Love and relationships have ultimate significance
• There’s a divine presence characterized by love
• Our choices matter eternally

While NDEs don’t prove Christianity specifically, they challenge materialism and open doors for gospel conversations. A software engineer who studied NDEs concluded, “I started as an atheist investigating NDEs to debunk them. The evidence convinced me consciousness survives death. If that’s true, maybe other spiritual claims deserve investigation. Today I’m a Christian.”

Theological Education

Churches should teach biblical anthropology more thoroughly, helping believers understand human nature through a trinitarian lens. Many Christians absorb cultural materialism without realizing it contradicts biblical teaching. Clear teaching on the soul’s reality and survival after death strengthens faith and prepares believers for evangelistic conversations.

Youth especially need this teaching as they encounter physicalist assumptions in education and media. When a teen’s biology teacher insists humans are just complex chemical reactions, they need solid theological grounding to maintain biblical faith. Understanding how Trinity doctrine illuminates human nature provides that foundation.

Common Questions About NDEs and Human Nature

Q: Don’t NDEs sometimes contain unbiblical elements like reincarnation or universalism?

A: Yes, some NDEs include elements that contradict Scripture. This reminds us that spiritual experiences must be tested against biblical truth (1 John 4:1). Not every spiritual experience is from God, and even genuine experiences can be misinterpreted. We should accept what aligns with Scripture while rejecting what contradicts it. The core elements of NDEs – consciousness surviving death, divine judgment based on love, transformation toward compassion – align well with biblical teaching. Secondary interpretations that contradict Scripture should be rejected.

Q: If the soul survives death, why does Scripture call death an enemy?

A: Death remains an enemy because it’s unnatural – God didn’t originally design humans to experience body-soul separation. Death entered through sin (Romans 5:12) and disrupts God’s good creation. While the soul survives, the separation from the body is traumatic and incomplete. We’re designed as unified beings, which is why God promises bodily resurrection, not just spiritual existence. Death is a defeated enemy whose ultimate destruction comes at the final resurrection.

Q: How can consciousness exist without a brain? Doesn’t this violate science?

A: This assumes consciousness is produced by the brain, but that’s a philosophical assumption, not a scientific fact. Science observes correlation between brain states and mental states but hasn’t proven causation. The hard problem of consciousness – explaining how subjective experience arises from objective processes – remains unsolved. If consciousness is fundamental rather than emergent, as the Trinity suggests, then it doesn’t require a brain to exist, though in normal human life it operates through the brain.

Q: Why don’t all people have NDEs during cardiac arrest?

A: Only about 10-20% of cardiac arrest survivors report NDEs, though this may underrepresent actual occurrences due to memory issues or reluctance to share. We don’t know why some have them and others don’t. Possible factors include depth of clinical death, individual spiritual sensitivity, divine purpose, or memory formation problems. The fact that not everyone reports them doesn’t invalidate the experiences of those who do, just as not everyone has dreams they remember, yet dreams are real.

Q: Could NDEs just be the brain’s way of coping with death?

A: This evolutionary explanation faces several problems. First, there’s no survival benefit to having pleasant experiences while dying – evolution would favor mechanisms that keep us alive, not make death comfortable. Second, this doesn’t explain veridical observations of events beyond sensory range. Third, it doesn’t account for NDEs in non-life-threatening situations. Fourth, the transformative aftereffects that often decrease evolutionary fitness (less materialistic, less competitive) argue against this being an evolved response.

Q: How should Christians view physicalist believers who deny the soul?

A: While physicalism contradicts biblical teaching and traditional Christian doctrine, many physicalist Christians are genuine believers trying to reconcile faith with what they see as scientific facts. We should engage graciously, showing how Scripture, theology, and evidence like NDEs point to substance dualism. The issue isn’t salvation – one can be saved without perfect theology – but faithfulness to biblical truth and its implications for life, death, and ministry.

Q: What about people who have negative or hellish NDEs?

A: While less commonly reported, negative NDEs do occur, often involving darkness, fear, or demonic beings. These align with biblical warnings about judgment and hell. Interestingly, many who have negative NDEs report calling out to God or Jesus and being rescued, consistent with “whoever calls on the name of the Lord shall be saved” (Romans 10:13). These experiences remind us that not all spiritual encounters are positive and that ultimate destiny depends on relationship with Christ.

Key Points Summary

Practical Application: Living as Trinitarian Image Bearers

Understanding human nature through the Trinity and the evidence from NDEs should transform how we live daily. We’re not accidental collections of atoms in a meaningless universe but purposefully created beings bearing the image of the triune God. Our consciousness reflects divine consciousness. Our capacity for relationship mirrors the eternal communion of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Our souls will outlast our bodies, continuing consciously after death until reunited with glorified bodies at the resurrection.

This truth calls us to:

1. Prioritize Eternal Realities: If consciousness survives death and we’ll review our lives from an eternal perspective, we should invest in what lasts – relationships, love, spiritual growth, kingdom impact. Every choice has eternal significance. Every person we meet is an eternal soul. Every act of love ripples into eternity.

2. Develop Spiritual Sensitivity: Since we have souls that transcend the physical, we should cultivate spiritual awareness through prayer, meditation on Scripture, worship, and spiritual disciplines. We’re not just training our brains but developing our souls – the part of us that continues after death.

3. Face Death with Hope: Understanding that death is temporary separation, not termination, transforms our approach to mortality. We grieve but not as those without hope (1 Thessalonians 4:13). We can comfort others with the truth that consciousness continues, that believers immediately enter Christ’s presence, and that resurrection will reunite soul and body.

4. Share the Gospel Boldly: If every person has an eternal soul that will consciously exist forever, the gospel becomes urgently important. Heaven and hell aren’t metaphors but eternal destinations for conscious souls. NDEs can open conversations with skeptics, challenging materialism and pointing toward spiritual reality.

5. Value Both Body and Soul: As psychosomatic unities imaging the Trinity, we should neither neglect the body (as Gnostics do) nor deny the soul (as physicalists do). We care for our bodies as temples of the Spirit while recognizing our identity transcends the physical. We pursue physical health and spiritual growth, knowing both matter but only one is eternal.

6. Practice Presence with the Dying: Knowing consciousness may continue even when bodies fail, we minister to dying people as whole persons, not just failing organisms. We speak truth, express love, offer forgiveness, and share Scripture, trusting their souls hear even when bodies can’t respond.

7. Live Relationally: Since we image the relational Trinity and NDEs emphasize love’s ultimate importance, we should prioritize relationships over achievements. Success means loving God and others well, not accumulating wealth or status. In eternity, we’ll value the lives we touched, not the things we acquired.

8. Rest in Trinitarian Love: The overwhelming message from NDEs is that divine love exceeds our imagination. The triune God who is love itself created us for loving relationship. Despite our failures, God’s love remains constant. This should free us from performance-based religion, leading to grateful worship and service.

Prayer and Reflection

Triune God – Father, Son, and Holy Spirit – we stand amazed that You created us in Your image. Thank You that we’re not accidents of evolution but purposefully designed beings reflecting Your nature. Thank You for the gift of consciousness that mirrors Your own personal awareness. Thank You that our souls bear Your image and will outlast our mortal bodies.

Lord Jesus, You who took on human nature know what it means to be embodied souls. You experienced the full range of human existence yet without sin. You faced death knowing Your human soul would separate from Your body, yet You entrusted Yourself to the Father. Thank You that through Your death and resurrection, death has lost its ultimate sting for us.

Holy Spirit, You who gives life and raised Christ from the dead, we thank You for dwelling within us. Help us understand the mystery of our nature – that we’re neither purely physical nor purely spiritual but complex unities reflecting the Trinity. Guide us to live with eternal perspective, investing in what lasts.

Father, we confess we often live as practical materialists, focusing on physical realities while neglecting spiritual ones. Forgive us for valuing temporary things over eternal relationships. Help us grasp that every person we meet bears Your image and possesses an eternal soul. Transform our priorities to match Your heart.

For those facing death – their own or a loved one’s – grant comfort in knowing consciousness continues, that absence from the body means presence with Christ for believers. Use even the phenomenon of NDEs to open blind eyes to spiritual reality and point people to the gospel.

Help us live as what we are – embodied souls created for eternal relationship with You. May we face each day knowing our choices echo in eternity, our love matters forever, and our souls will one day stand before You. Until that day, may we faithfully bear Your image in a world that’s forgotten its Creator.

In the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit – one God in three persons, in whose triune image we’re wonderfully made. Amen.

Bibliography

Alexander, Eben. Proof of Heaven: A Neurosurgeon’s Journey into the Afterlife. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2012.

Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologiae. Translated by Fathers of the English Dominican Province. London: Burns, Oates & Washbourne, 1920.

Augustine of Hippo. On the Trinity. Translated by Arthur West Haddan. Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing, 1887.

Cooper, John W. Body, Soul, and Life Everlasting: Biblical Anthropology and the Monism-Dualism Debate. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000.

Goetz, Stewart, and Charles Taliaferro. A Brief History of the Soul. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.

Green, Joel B. Body, Soul, and Human Life: The Nature of Humanity in the Bible. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2008.

Greyson, Bruce. After: A Doctor Explores What Near-Death Experiences Reveal about Life and Beyond. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2021.

Habermas, Gary R., and J.P. Moreland. Beyond Death: Exploring the Evidence for Immortality. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2004.

Holden, Janice Miner, Bruce Greyson, and Debbie James, eds. The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences: Thirty Years of Investigation. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2009.

Irenaeus of Lyons. Against Heresies. Translated by Alexander Roberts and William Rambaut. Buffalo, NY: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885.

Long, Jeffrey, with Paul Perry. Evidence of the Afterlife: The Science of Near-Death Experiences. New York: HarperOne, 2010.

Moody, Raymond. Life After Life: The Investigation of a Phenomenon – Survival of Bodily Death. 25th Anniversary Edition. San Francisco: HarperOne, 2001.

Moreland, J.P. The Soul: How We Know It’s Real and Why It Matters. Chicago: Moody Publishers, 2014.

Murphy, Nancey. Bodies and Souls, or Spirited Bodies? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

Parnia, Sam. Erasing Death: The Science That Is Rewriting the Boundaries Between Life and Death. New York: HarperOne, 2013.

Parnia, Sam, et al. “AWARE—AWAreness during REsuscitation—A Prospective Study.” Resuscitation 85, no. 12 (2014): 1799-1805.

Ring, Kenneth, and Sharon Cooper. Mindsight: Near-Death and Out-of-Body Experiences in the Blind. 2nd ed. Bloomington, IN: iUniverse, 2008.

Sabom, Michael. Recollections of Death: A Medical Investigation. New York: Harper & Row, 1982.

Storm, Howard. My Descent Into Death: A Second Chance at Life. New York: Doubleday, 2005.

Swinburne, Richard. Mind, Brain, and Free Will. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.

van Lommel, Pim. Consciousness Beyond Life: The Science of the Near-Death Experience. New York: HarperOne, 2010.

van Lommel, Pim, et al. “Near-Death Experience in Survivors of Cardiac Arrest: A Prospective Study in the Netherlands.” The Lancet 358, no. 9298 (2001): 2039-2045.

Wright, N.T. Surprised by Hope: Rethinking Heaven, the Resurrection, and the Mission of the Church. New York: HarperOne, 2008.

© 2025, DakeBible.org. All rights reserved.